September 28, 2026
This report was prepared by the Law Office of J.R. Howell, counsel in the lawsuit discussed. Its evidence includes the filed complaint, executed agreements, agency records obtained through public-records requests, official legislative captions, agency policies, contractor reports and contemporaneous correspondence. The source index links complete records alongside selected excerpts. PDF citations count from the first page of each file; complaint paragraph numbers provide an additional reference.
The November 5, 2025 letters identify six agreements, describe allegedly continuing bank access and other commercial uses of personal information, and request investigation and reforms. They are marked for email and UPS delivery. GO-Biz’s letter addresses the official occupying its designated Privacy Officer position and refers to earlier correspondence about the public-records requests. [L07] [L08] [L10, PDF p. 2]
J.R. Howell, the letters’ sender, reports that neither office answered or followed up, and reaffirmed that account on September 28, 2026. This is the source of the report’s current response history, identified as N01. The letters independently document the warnings and requests; the supplied record contains no independent delivery confirmation. The report does not infer that Governor Newsom personally read them. The November letters give August 18 for an earlier claim’s service; the complaint gives August 15 for its presentation. The chronology preserves that discrepancy. [L07, PDF p. 1] [L08, PDF p. 1] [L01, PDF p. 16, ¶51]
L01 is the complete 99-page filed petition and complaint in Los Angeles Superior Court case 26STCV24726, endorsed August 5, 2026. Its three signed verifications apply to the writ petition and allegations incorporated into that count, including matters stated on information and belief as beliefs. They expressly do not verify the other counts. The allegations have not been adjudicated. The report covers the complete pleading: its constitutional and statutory foundation, all information channels, oversight and continuing duties, individual experiences and injuries, class allegations, five counts and requested relief. [L01, PDF pp. 1, 18–99]
The complaint’s defined Applicant Data excludes information that an applicant lawfully made public. [L01, PDF p. 11, ¶28]
The report distinguishes firsthand experiences described in the pleading, technical practices alleged on information and belief, documentary contract terms and independently available official records. Allegations that companies processed information for product development or training are presented as allegations about the systems in this case. Use of AI or an automated processor alone does not establish that every submitted document trained a model. Code, marketing materials and general product capabilities have a different evidentiary role from logs proving a particular transfer, retention period or downstream use. [L01, PDF pp. 15, 30–32, 39–52, ¶¶50, 112–122, 152–214]
The complaint distinguishes experiences described by the plaintiffs from technical matters pleaded on information and belief. Paragraph 152 identifies published technical materials, portal code and absent controls as the basis for its account of continuing bank access. The pleading supplies no bank-access log establishing a specific retrieval schedule. Paragraph 160 alleges recurring retrieval; the broader allegation of daily data use in paragraph 56 does not establish daily bank downloads. [L01, PDF pp. 15, 17, 39–41, ¶¶50, 56, 152–160]
The program guide documents what selected applicants were told, including verification purposes, sharing assurances and alternative methods when a bank was unavailable through the preferred provider. The sick-leave agreement contains scope-of-work language about funding selected applicants and an accepted proposal placing bank connectivity before submission of a complete application. Both parts are preserved. Neither the guide nor the proposal establishes what every applicant encountered or proves subsequent commercial harvesting. [V01, PDF pp. 49, 56] [F08, PDF pp. 2, 4, 17–18]
Technical categories and class membership are not interchangeable. The complaint identifies different firsthand interactions for different individuals. Its class definitions reach California citizens whose personal information was included in covered applications from January 1, 2020 onward, including people named in another person’s application. They do not establish that every proposed member experienced every channel or sustained the same damage. [L01, PDF pp. 64, 66–68, 87, ¶¶269–271, 281–293, 373]
The approximately $201.7 million figure is GO-Biz budget officer Philip Chen’s answer in the Legislature’s official captions for April 23, 2024. The report attributes it to the agency; the audio was not independently transcribed for this investigation. The signed agreement separately acknowledges $174,877,000 in earlier administrative payments. Those amounts overlap and are not added. They do not measure profit, public losses or an identified privacy-only budget. [F01, 01:35:57–01:36:38] [F02, PDF pp. 1, 7]
Contract budgets and ceilings establish authorized or estimated amounts; they are not independently verified payments. Reported awards, business applicants and natural persons are different measures. CalOSBA reported 330,023 flagship-program awards and more than 350,000 business and nonprofit applicants in the first two rounds. Neither establishes how many individuals linked accounts or belong to a class. [F11, PDF p. 24] [V05]
The December 17, 2024 request expressly sought internal or external audits, evaluations, performance reviews, findings and corrective actions. The matching production contains ten contractor reports totaling 94 pages. Six describe annual SOC reporting; the Dream Fund report describes penetration testing. None supplies an underlying assessment or an agency privacy-compliance audit. A11 links the complete inventory and originals. This finding concerns that production rather than all records that could exist elsewhere. [V04, PDF p. 2] [V03, PDF p. 1] [A11]
The response prints April 25, 2024, but its metadata records April 25, 2025, consistent with the supplied folder and the December 2024 request. The report describes an April 2025 production while preserving the original discrepancy. [V03]
Section 1798.19 requires application of IPA protections to covered outsourced records; it does not prescribe one mandatory sentence. Section 1798.25’s accounting duty concerns specified disclosures and exceptions. The report distinguishes personal information about individuals from business information generally. Its agency comparisons concern published procedures within each agency’s scope, including CalHFA’s route to outside-servicer records. [L13] [L15] [S09] [R02, PDF pp. 6–7]
Section 1798.15 favors direct collection to the greatest extent practicable. Section 1798.16 has source-record exceptions. Section 1798.27 generally requires disclosure accountings to be retained for at least three years or until the record is destroyed, whichever is shorter. Section 1798.60 specifically addresses commercial distribution, sale or rental of names and addresses absent statutory authorization. The report describes the statutory obligations with these boundaries and distinguishes the broader vendor inventory requested as injunctive relief. [L13] [L15] [S13] [L01, PDF p. 95]
The security discussion identifies the applicable executive-entity path under Government Code section 11549.3(b) and the State Administrative Manual. The distinct biennial-assessment provision in subdivision (f) applies to agencies outside that path; it is not treated as a universal requirement imposed on GO-Biz. Current statutory text and its amendment notes are linked, and the report does not assume every present standard applied in identical form to every historical contract. [S08] [S19, PDF pp. 5, 22] [S01] [S02] [S03]
The complaint’s constitutional history supports its statutory claims. The filed action contains no separate constitutional cause of action. Three counts seek equitable relief and two seek liability with individual damage amounts reserved. Government Code section 815.6 includes mandatory-duty, protective-purpose and causation requirements and a reasonable-diligence defense; the report identifies the theory without representing that its elements have been adjudicated. [L01, PDF pp. 69–96] [L19]
The pleading invokes the Superior Court’s authority over mandamus, declarations, injunctions and the IPA’s civil remedies, with venue tied to the applicants, records and alleged effects in Los Angeles County. It names the State, GO-Biz, CalOSBA, the directors in their official capacities and unidentified State officials or agencies. Its definitions do not turn the unidentified defendants into the private contractor or vendors. [L01, PDF pp. 11–18, ¶¶32–58]
For the monetary claims, the complaint alleges a government claim presented to the Department of General Services in August 2025 and no written rejection or untimeliness notice within the period it identifies. It pleads claim-presentation compliance or waiver and theories of continuing duties, delayed discovery and statutory timeliness. Those are pleaded grounds for proceeding, not rulings on limitations or claim compliance. The first three counts seek equitable relief and distinguish their incorporated allegations from the monetary claims. [L01, PDF pp. 16–18, 69, 73–74, 77, 81–82, 88, ¶¶51–58, 294, 314, 323, 347, 378]
The contracts contain general privacy and security promises. Their reporting, retention, inspection and channel-closure provisions establish agreed obligations, rather than independently verified performance, current holdings or actual shutdown dates. The investigation examines what those obligations required the administration to oversee and what the available records show it did. [F04, PDF pp. 14–18] [F05, PDF pp. 9–12] [F08, PDF pp. 6, 19]
The CEO quotation is reproduced from complaint paragraph 117. Counsel reports listening to the recording; the source library does not contain an independently linked original recording. The State’s accepted proposal independently describes automated decisioning followed by additional human review. The earlier Plaid settlement is supported by its final approval order and did not adjudicate California’s implementation; the November letters did not name that earlier litigation. [L01, PDF p. 31] [F08, PDF p. 17] [J01] [L07] [L08]
Lendistry’s current privacy policy is dated May 6, 2026. Its no-sale statement and account of contractual limits describe the company’s published position, not the historical terms presented to every grant applicant. [V06]